Is a Milkshake a Drink or Dessert? The Ultimate Debate!

A milkshake is both a drink and a dessert. It is a sweet, creamy beverage that is commonly consumed after a meal or as a treat.

The drink is typically made with ice cream, milk, and a flavoring such as chocolate or strawberry. Milkshakes have been popular in the united states since the early 20th century. They are often available at fast food restaurants and diners, and can also be made at home using a blender.

Some variations of the milkshake include adding fruit, candy, or other sweeteners. Although milkshakes do contain some nutritional value from the milk and possibly fruit, they are generally considered a treat due to their high sugar and calorie content. Therefore, while the milkshake may technically be classified as a drink, it is more commonly thought of as a dessert.

Is a Milkshake a Drink or Dessert? The Ultimate Debate!


What Defines A Milkshake?

Is A Milkshake A Drink Or Dessert? The Ultimate Debate!

Milkshakes have always been a go-to for many as a thirst quencher or dessert. But have you ever wondered, is a milkshake a drink or dessert? Well, the jury is still out on that one. Let’s explore what defines a milkshake and try to decipher the ultimate debate.

The Origin Story Of The Milkshake

Milkshakes were first served in the late 19th century. The earliest form of milkshake was simply a mixture of cold milk, flavored syrup, and soda water. Milkshakes were sold at soda fountains, which were popular hangout spots for teenagers of the era.

By the 1930s, ice cream had become the main ingredient in milkshakes, and the blender had replaced the malt mixer. Today, milkshakes have evolved into an art form of its own, with an endless array of flavors to choose from.

The Classic Milkshake Recipe

The classic milkshake recipe is simple and requires only a few ingredients. It typically includes milk, ice cream, and syrup. Here’s how to make a classic milkshake:

  • In a blender, add 2-3 scoops of vanilla ice cream.
  • Pour in 1/2 cup of milk.
  • Add 2-3 tablespoons of flavored syrup.
  • Blend until smooth.
  • Pour into a glass and serve immediately.

Evolution Of The Milkshake: Variations And Add-Ons

Over the years, milkshakes have seen many variations and add-ons that make them even more delicious. Some popular add-ons include whipped cream, chocolate chips, sprinkles, and fruit. Here are some popular milkshake variations:

  • Banana milkshake: Add a ripe banana to the classic recipe and blend until smooth
  • Chocolate milkshake: Add chocolate syrup or cocoa powder to the classic recipe
  • Strawberry milkshake: Add fresh or frozen strawberries to the classic recipe

Milkshakes today are not just limited to the ingredients that go into them, but also the unique presentation styles that leave us in awe.

Whether you see a milkshake as a drink or dessert, one thing is certain – it’s a treat that everyone loves. With its rich history, classic recipe, and endless variations and add-ons, the milkshake is truly an iconic drink or dessert that stands the test of time.

Milkshake As A Drink: Arguments For And Against

Milkshakes are a classic american treat loved by many. However, the ongoing debate on whether milkshakes are a drink or a dessert never seems to end. Some people believe that milkshakes are a refreshing drink, while others argue that with its sweetness and thickness, it should be considered a dessert.

This post will discuss milkshakes as a drink and the arguments for and against it.

Nutritional Value Of Milkshakes: Is It Healthy To Drink?

Milkshakes are delicious and irresistible, but they’re also known for their high sugar and calorie content. Here are some points to consider regarding the nutritional value of milkshakes:

See also  Can You Make a Milkshake with Yogurt? Yes, and Here's How!
  • Milkshakes are high in sugar content, which can lead to health problems such as obesity, diabetes, and tooth decay.
  • On average, a single milkshake can contain roughly 700-800 calories, which exceeds the recommended daily calorie intake for most individuals.
  • However, milkshakes can also have some nutritional value, especially when made using fresh fruits or low-fat milk.
  • Milkshakes can provide a good source of calcium, and vitamins such as vitamin d and potassium, depending on the ingredients used.

Milkshakes Vs. Other Beverage Options: A Comparison

Milkshakes may be the perfect treat for some, but how do they compare to other beverage options? Here are some points to consider:

  • Compared to other drinks, such as soda or energy drinks, milkshakes contain more calories and sugar.
  • In comparison to other sweet drinks, such as smoothies or shakes, milkshakes tend to have a higher fat content.
  • However, milkshakes are a better option for those looking for a quick and tasty way to consume high amounts of protein, vitamins, and minerals, especially when made with ingredients such as fresh fruit, nuts, and low-fat milk.

The Practicality Of The Milkshake: Suitability For Different Scenarios

Milkshakes are perfect for various situations. Here are some points to consider:

  • Milkshakes can be a refreshing drink on a hot summer day.
  • They can serve as an excellent breakfast option, providing a quick and easy meal replacement for those on the go.
  • Milkshakes can also be a fantastic dessert option, satisfying those sweet cravings, and providing a satisfactory end to a delicious meal.

Milkshakes are a delicious and irresistible treat, but when it comes to whether they are a drink or a dessert, it’s all a matter of perspective. While milkshakes may be high in sugar and calories, they can also provide nutritional value and serve as an excellent source of vitamins and minerals.

It all comes down to personal preference and lifestyle choices.

Milkshake As A Dessert: Arguments For And Against

Enjoying Milkshakes In Social Situations: Is It A Dessert Or A Beverage?

Milkshakes are a popular beverage known for their creamy and sweet texture. It is hard not to enjoy a delicious milkshake, whether alone or with friends. However, it is still widely debated whether milkshakes are a beverage or dessert. Let us explore the arguments for milkshakes as a dessert.

  • Milkshakes are often served in a glass that is similar to those used for other desserts such as sundaes or ice cream floats.
  • Many milkshake recipes include sweet toppings such as whipped cream, chocolate syrup, or sprinkles. These ingredients are more commonly associated with desserts than with beverages.
  • Milkshakes can be very filling, often containing a high calorie count and a lot of sugar. Those qualities make it more like a dessert than a refreshing beverage.

The Role Of Milkshake In Dessert-Making: Substitution Or Unique Ingredient?

Milkshakes can be a versatile ingredient in dessert-making. It can either be used as a substitution for other dairy products or as a unique ingredient that can make a dessert much more special.

  • Milkshakes can be used to replace milk or cream in many dessert recipes, resulting in a lighter and more refreshing dish.
  • It can also be added to other desserts, such as cakes, brownies, or pudding, to give them a unique and delightful taste.
  • Milkshakes can be a perfect base for other dessert drinks, such as frappes or smoothies.

Health Concerns Related To Milkshakes: Should It Be Limited To Dessert?

While it is true that milkshakes are sweet, creamy, and delicious, they are not always the most healthy option. As such, there may be concerns about drinking milkshakes.

  • Due to their high sugar content, milkshakes can contribute to weight gain and other health issues like diabetes. It is important to enjoy milkshakes in moderation.
  • Milkshakes contain high levels of fat, and for those with dietary restrictions such as lactose intolerance, they may not be the best choice.
  • To make it a healthier option, you can choose low-fat or non-dairy milkshakes, or limit consumption to once in a while.
See also  What Is a Hand Spun Milkshake: A Decadent Treat!

The debate over whether a milkshake is a dessert or a beverage is a subjective matter. However, it is important to keep in mind the health concerns related to it. Ultimately, moderation is key when it comes to enjoying this delicious treat.

The Final Verdict: Milkshake As A Dessert Or Drink?

Are milkshakes a drink or dessert? It’s a question that has been debated for decades. Some argue that milkshakes fall under the beverage category while others firmly believe that they are a type of dessert. So which is it? Let’s dive in and examine the historical perspective, pros and cons, and ultimately reach a personal verdict.

Historical Perspective On Milkshake, Dessert, And Beverage

Milkshakes were first introduced in the late 1800s as a health drink made with milk, eggs, and whiskey. They were often used as a way to soothe upset stomachs and were not considered a sweet beverage. As time went on, ice cream was added to the mix, and the flavor options became endless.

The debate around whether a milkshake is a dessert or a drink stems from this evolution in its history.

A Holistic View On Pros And Cons Of Milkshake Ingestion

Like any food or beverage, there are pros and cons to consuming milkshakes. Let’s take a holistic look at some of them:


  • Milkshakes can be a source of calcium and protein.
  • They can be a satisfying treat on a hot day.
  • Milkshakes can provide a quick boost of energy.
  • They come in a variety of flavors and can be customized to individual tastes.
  • They can be a fun treat to enjoy with friends and family.


  • Milkshakes can be high in calories, sugar, and fat.
  • Some people may have lactose intolerance or dairy allergies, making milkshakes off-limits.
  • Drinking too many milkshakes can lead to weight gain and other health issues.

The Ultimate Debate Decoded: A Personal Opinion

In my personal opinion, a milkshake is more of a dessert than a drink. While milkshakes may contain milk and are consumed as a beverage, they often contain a large amount of ice cream, whipped cream, and other sugary toppings that tip the scales towards dessert territory.

The debate around whether a milkshake is a drink or dessert will likely go on for many years to come. Ultimately, it comes down to personal perspective, preferences, and beliefs. Whether you enjoy your milkshake as a drink or dessert, be mindful of its nutritional value and consume it in moderation.


After analyzing the various aspects of milkshakes, it can be concluded that they can be both a drink and a dessert. While milkshakes are typically served in a glass with a straw, they also contain ingredients commonly found in desserts such as ice cream and syrups.

Milkshakes are often consumed as a sweet treat, but they can also be consumed as a refreshing beverage to quench thirst. Furthermore, the versatility of milkshakes allows for customization to personal preferences. Whether it be a classic chocolate milkshake or a fruity smoothie-like drink, there is something for everyone.

Ultimately, the categorization of milkshakes can vary based on the context in which they are being served and consumed. Regardless of classification, milkshakes remain a delicious and enjoyable addition to any meal or snack.

Share your love

Hi, I'm Emily Jones! I'm a health enthusiast and foodie, and I'm passionate about juicing, smoothies, and all kinds of nutritious beverages. Through my popular blog, I share my knowledge and love for healthy drinks with others.