A milkshake is primarily considered a drink, as it is a blended beverage made from milk, ice cream, and flavorings, enjoyed through a straw.
The milkshake sits in a delicious gray area between food and drink. With its thick, spoonable texture yet drinkable nature, this creamy treat defies simple categorization. Let’s explore what makes milkshakes unique and why they might qualify as both.
The Case for Milkshakes as Drinks
Milkshakes share many characteristics with traditional beverages:
- Served in cups or glasses with straws
- Consumed primarily for hydration and refreshment
- Often accompany meals rather than replace them
- Classified as “beverages” on most restaurant menus
The best blenders for milkshakes create smooth, drinkable textures that flow easily through a straw. Many establishments like movie theaters and diners group milkshakes with sodas and other drinks on their menus.
Nutritional Profile as a Beverage
Compared to solid foods, milkshakes:
| Characteristic | Milkshake | Typical Food |
|---|---|---|
| Texture | Liquid | Solid |
| Primary Consumption Method | Sipping | Chewing |
| Digestion Speed | Fast | Slow |
The Case for Milkshakes as Food
Despite their drinkable nature, milkshakes possess several food-like qualities:
- High calorie density (often 500+ calories)
- Contains substantial nutrients (protein, calcium, vitamins)
- Can serve as a meal replacement
- Requires preparation similar to other foods
As noted by WoodTalk Online, the nutritional content makes milkshakes function more like food than typical beverages. The best ice cream for milkshakes contributes significant food value beyond just hydration.
When Milkshakes Become Meals
Some milkshakes cross firmly into food territory:
- Protein shakes used as post-workout recovery meals
- Meal replacement shakes for medical or dietary needs
- Extreme milkshakes loaded with cookies, candy, and other solid foods
The Verdict: Both Food and Drink
Milkshakes exist in a unique culinary category that blends characteristics of both food and beverages. Their classification depends on context:
- As drinks: When consumed casually for refreshment
- As food: When providing substantial nutrition or replacing meals
This dual nature explains why milkshakes appear in both beverage menus and dessert sections. Their versatility makes them beloved whether you’re looking for a sweet drink or an indulgent treat.
“`
